Great Serpent Mound = Adena

The Western Hemisphere. General term for the Americas following their discovery by Europeans, thus setting them in contradistinction to the Old World of Africa, Europe, and Asia.

Moderators: MichelleH, Minimalist

Post Reply

Great Serpent Mound = Adena

Post by uniface » Tue Aug 12, 2014 11:30 am

Geoffrey Sea,

Serpent Mound in rural Adams County, Ohio, is one of the premier Native American earthworks in the hemisphere. Its pristine flowing form was enhanced by major reconstruction in the 1880s. That reconstruction now appears to have been the second time in its long life that Serpent Mound has shed some of its skin.

Estimates of the age of the earthwork are now radically revised as the result of a new radiocarbon analysis, suggesting that the mound is about 1,400 years older than conventionally thought. The new date of construction is estimated at approximately 321 BCE, one year after the death of Aristotle in Greece.

Signs and other interpretive material have been made obsolete virtually overnight, along with ideas about the indigenous culture responsible for the astounding artwork. A paper by an eight-member team led by archaeologist William Romain has been published in the Journal of Archaeological Science with a free-access summary available on Romain's website. ... s-old.html

The new data alters thinking about three things: the culture responsible for the mound; the Native groups that are direct descendants of those builders; and the purpose and iconography of the work.

Dispatching other theories about Serpent Mound's origin, Romain's summary concludes: "Both the consensus of opinion and radiocarbon evidence suggest an Adena construction."

Traditionally, Serpent Mound was attributed to the Adena Culture or Civilization, based on an adjacent conical Adena burial mound, and the similarity of style of the effigy with many other Adena earthworks of the Ohio Valley. Just 30 miles southeast of Serpent Mound were the Portsmouth Works, with only a few surviving remnants, interpreted by the pioneering archaeoastronomer Stansbury Hagar as representing the effigy of a rattlesnake 50 times larger than Serpent Mound, both with species identification features indicative of the timber rattlesnake.

However, an investigation in the 1990s found two charcoal samples in Serpent Mound that dated to the later time of about 1070 CE. Site managers then attributed construction to the Late Woodland "Fort Ancient Culture," even though the so-called "Fort Ancient Culture" has been disassociated from the Fort Ancient earthwork in Warren County, Ohio, and is not known to have built large earthworks. Indeed it has been misnamed a "culture" and is now understood more as an interaction phenomenon involving multiple ethnolinguistic groups that came together in the Ohio Valley in the Late Woodland Period, between 500 CE and 1200 CE.

"Fort Ancient Culture" is neither a fort, nor ancient, nor a culture. Yet it has been identified as the author of Serpent Mound, except in those circles where the mound has been attributed to giants or space aliens or giant space aliens.

The "Fort Ancient" designation has been problematic, because as an unreal entity, the so-called culture has no clear descendants. Adena, on the contrary, is strongly identified from archaeology, genetics, and historical linguistics as Algonquian, its descendants being the Anishinaabeg, the Miami-Illinois, the Shawnee, the Kickapoo, the Meskwaki, and the Asakiwaki.

The new investigation by Romain and others found much older charcoal samples in less-damaged sections of the mound. The investigators conjecture that the mound was originally built between 381 BCE and 44 BCE, with a mean date of 321 BCE. They explain the more recent charcoal found in the 1990s as likely the result of a "repair" effort by Indians around 1070 CE, when the mound would already have been suffering from natural degradation. Late Woodland Period graves at the site suggest the earthwork continued to serve a mortuary function, and that this was the principal nature of the site, directing spirits of the dead from burial mounds and subsurface graves northward, not a place to conduct large ceremonial gatherings as has been suggested by tourism/promotion interests.

Without Serpent Mound as a "ceremonial center" at its geographic core, the notion of a "Fort Ancient Culture" has literally been gutted.

That the new date adds a very sophisticated earthwork to the corpus of the Adena, whom some had considered "primitive," lends new weight to reconsideration of the non-distinction between "Adena" and "Hopewell" and the need for a general revision of the naming conventions for prehistoric cultures of the Ohio Valley. A simplified revised chronology would see the Adena Civilization leading straight to the historic Central Algonquian tribes in the heartland of the Ohio Valley.

The new study comes just as Serpent Mound is being advanced for addition to the UNESCO World Heritage List, a nomination that will have to be rethought as a result of the new date and its implications. Members of the Central Algonquian tribes now have scientific claim to be considered the heirs of Serpent Mound, raising questions about the structure of site management, now conducted by the Ohio History Connection and Arc of Appalachia Preserve System.

What is certain is that ancient Ohioans were not only building extremely sophisticated geometric works that rivalled or surpassed those of contemporary classical Greece, but they were also repairing or renovating them over millennia. ... we-thought

E.P. Grondine

Re: Great Serpent Mound = Adena

Post by E.P. Grondine » Wed Aug 13, 2014 11:52 am

In my opinion, Geoffrey is more than a little confused as to population groups. See my note to him here: ... ffrey-sea/

In any case, Brad Lepper's analysis of Serpent Mound has now collapsed.
It will be interesting to read Bill Romaine's book learn HIS own thinking on these matters, instead of Mr. Sea's.

IN sum, there were no "Adena". There were Andaste, marked by X mt DNA.
And yes, they were tall.

"Late Fort Ancient Culture", depending on how you define it, is known to be Shawnee.
The other peoples listed by Sea are spurious, part of the continued colonists' attempt to steal Shawnee lands and history.
Last edited by E.P. Grondine on Sun Aug 17, 2014 12:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.


Re: Great Serpent Mound = Adena

Post by uniface » Wed Aug 13, 2014 7:54 pm

IN sum, there were no "Adena". There were Andaste
This is beyond tedious.

In the 1960s (as I have told you) I knew an elderly Susquehannoc who had grown up the old way -- one of a group so raised as an investment by the tribe to keep living memory of the old ways. When I asked him if they had perhaps collected artifacts uncovered in their fields and gardens he laughed, asking, "If you are digging your garden and turn up old rusty tin cans and broken bottles, do you pick them up and save them ? Once we had steel knives and axes what would we want stone ones for ?"

Fast forward to our age, in which the White Man is the Cancer of History, and every (nick-)name he has ever given to any other people must be rejected and repudiated as White Man Evil, no matter how long it has been in common use. Not to mention that "Indian artifacts" are now precious Cultural Patrimony that, in more and more places, may not be collected under penalty of law.

It was 100% healthier before.

Your Wellwisher,

The White Devil :twisted:

E.P. Grondine

Re: Great Serpent Mound = Adena

Post by E.P. Grondine » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:57 pm

A message from a great New Zeland native rights leader:

Post Reply